SPEAKING AS someone who will shamelessly eat peanut butter straight from the jar, I totally get the obsession. If you’re here, you probably know someone who feels the same — the kind of person who lights up at the sight of a peanut butter cup, always has a jar within reach, or just thinks peanut butter makes everything better. Maybe you’re shopping for their birthday, a holiday, or just because you want to surprise them with something awesome.
Whatever the reason, you’ve come to the right place. Below, you’ll find a list of thoughtful, fun, and downright delicious gifts perfect for the peanut butter lover in your life.
Awesome Gifts for the Peanut Butter Lover
1. Personalized Spoon
There’s no shame in digging straight into the jar — in fact, it’s the superior method. This personalized peanut butter spoon makes it official. Add their name so everyone knows: this jar is spoken for. It’s a simple, funny, and totally perfect gift for the true spoonful enthusiast.
2. Peanut Butter Coffee
For the peanut butter lover who’s truly committed, why not start the day with it in your coffee? This peanut butter-flavored brew is a delicious way to sneak a little nutty goodness into their morning routine. It’s fun, it’s bold, and honestly, anyone who says it’s “too much” just doesn’t get it.
3. Peanut Butter Squeeze Packs
Peanut butter emergencies are real — and these squeeze packs are the perfect backup plan. Toss them in a bag, keep them in the car, or stash a few in your desk drawer. Wherever life takes you, you’ll never have to be far from your one true love: peanut butter.
4. Peanut Butter Cookbook
Sure, peanut butter on toast is great — but that’s just the beginning. This peanut butter cookbook is packed with creative, drool-worthy recipes where peanut butter is the main event. Sweet, savory, snacks, even dinners — it’s all here. Perfect for the peanut butter lover who’s ready to take their obsession to the next level.
5. Peanut Butter Mixer
If you love natural peanut butter but dread the oil slick on top, this is a total game-changer. This peanut butter mixer makes that messy, arm-workout stirring a thing of the past. Smooth, easy, no spills — so you can keep buying your favorite natural jars without the hassle.
6. Peanut Butter T-shirt
Let them wear their peanut butter pride loud and proud. Whether it’s a funny saying, a cute graphic, or just a big peanut butter jar on the front, this T-shirt is perfect for the fan who wants the whole world to know where their heart (and taste buds) truly belong.
7. Peanut Butter Socks
Because true peanut butter love goes from head to toe. These playful peanut butter socks are the perfect cozy gift for the fan who can’t get enough — and they make a great conversation starter, too. Comfortable, quirky, and totally on brand for the peanut butter obsessed.
8. Baked Peanut Butter Cookies
Sometimes you just need that perfect, soft, peanut buttery bite — and these cookies deliver. Freshly baked and packed with that rich, nutty flavor we all crave, they’re a sweet little way to make any peanut butter lover’s day. Honestly, good luck not eating the whole pack.
9. Peanut Butter Wall Art
For the peanut butter lover who’s not afraid to show it off — even on their walls. This fun, peanut butter-themed art is a playful way to add some personality to their space and proudly declare their nutty devotion. Perfect for a kitchen, office, or anywhere that could use a little peanut butter joy.
10. Peanut Butter Knife
If you’ve ever battled to get those last stubborn bits from the bottom of the jar, this is your weapon of choice. This peanut butter knife is perfectly shaped to stir, spread, and scrape every last swipe of goodness. No more wasting the precious stuff — every bit belongs to you.
11. Peanut Butter Mug
For the peanut butter lover who wants to start their day with a smile (and maybe a spoonful). Whether it’s for coffee, tea, or a late-night peanut butter snack, this mug is a cute, everyday reminder of their favorite obsession. Perfect for cozy mornings and showing a little peanut butter pride.
12. Peanut Butter Throw Pillow Case
Why not make your love for peanut butter part of your home décor? This peanut butter-themed throw pillow case is a fun, cozy way to add personality to your space. It’s the perfect conversation starter and a daily reminder of what really matters: peanut butter.
13. Peanut Butter Scented Candle
Imagine walking into a room that smells like warm, sweet peanut butter — pure bliss. This peanut butter scented candle is the perfect gift for the fan who wishes they could live in a peanut butter jar. It’s cozy, fun, and guaranteed to make their space smell deliciously nutty.
14. Peanut Butter Shower Curtain
For the peanut butter lover who’s truly all in. This peanut butter-themed shower curtain is the perfect way to keep the obsession going — even in the bathroom. It’s quirky, fun, and totally over-the-top in the best way. Because honestly, why should you have to be apart from peanut butter, even for a quick shower?
15. Peanut Butter Tote Bag
For errands, gym days, or hauling snacks (hopefully peanut butter ones), this tote bag lets them carry their peanut butter pride wherever they go. It’s cute, practical, and a fun way to let the world know what’s really fueling their day.