There’s something special about an engagement anniversary. Unlike a wedding anniversary—which often gets all the attention—this one celebrates the moment everything changed. It’s the “yes” that led to the aisle, the ring that started it all. Whether it’s your first year or your fifteenth, marking the day you got engaged is a sentimental gesture that deserves more than a quick dinner reservation.
And let’s be honest: if you’re here, you’re probably scrambling for a gift that feels thoughtful but doesn’t scream “I forgot.” Or maybe you didn’t forget—you just want to make them feel as important as they did the day you popped the question or said yes. Either way, we’ve rounded up some of the best engagement anniversary gifts that are sweet, meaningful, and don’t require a proposal-level budget.
Engagement Anniversary Gift for Him
1. Personalized Watch Box
If he’s been growing a small collection of watches (or just treasures the two he owns), a sleek personalized watch box will elevate his dresser game. It keeps things organized, dust-free, and stylish—and the personalization adds that extra sentimental touch without going overboard. Great for the guy who’s always on time or, let’s be honest, trying to be.
2. Whiskey Stones Gift Set
A classic, masculine gift that says “I see you” without being cheesy. A good whiskey stone set—especially one that comes with a couple of nice glasses and a wooden box—can turn an average Tuesday night pour into something that feels special. Bonus points if you pair it with his favorite bottle.
3. Custom Coordinates Keychain
Want to make him tear up a little (in a good way)? Give him a keychain engraved with the coordinates of where you got engaged. It’s small, subtle, and surprisingly emotional. He’ll carry it everywhere, and it’ll be a quiet reminder of that moment every time he grabs his keys.
4. Bluetooth Record Player
If your guy is into music, a Bluetooth record player is the perfect mix of vintage cool and modern convenience. You can drop a needle on vinyl together—or stream music from your phone when you’re feeling lazy. It’s romantic, nostalgic, and earns major points if you gift it alongside a vinyl of “your song.”
5. Adventure Book Journal
This is one of those gifts that looks simple but hits deep. An “Adventure Book” is perfect for documenting your past memories and planning new ones. Whether you’ve traveled the world together or just like dreaming out loud on the couch, it’s a sentimental way to reflect on where you’ve been—and where you’re headed.
6. Personalized Docking Station
If his nightstand looks like a tech jungle (phone, watch, AirPods, loose change), a personalized docking station might just change his life—or at least tidy up his side of the bed. These wood or leather organizers come with compartments for everything and can be engraved with his name, initials, or even a short message. It’s practical, sleek, and feels way more thoughtful than just handing him another charging cable.
7. Leather Travel Dopp Kit
Even if he’s not a frequent traveler, a quality leather dopp kit is one of those grown-up gifts every guy should have. It gives him a place to store his grooming essentials in style—no more using a ziplock bag for a toothbrush and cologne. Look for one that’s water-resistant and has a soft leather finish. It’s the kind of upgrade he’ll never buy for himself but will appreciate every time he packs.
8. Engraved Pocket Knife
Hear us out—this isn’t just for campers or outdoorsy guys. A pocket knife engraved with your anniversary date or initials can be surprisingly sentimental. It’s something he’ll keep for years, toss into a drawer or backpack, and rediscover with a smile. Whether he uses it to open boxes, slice apples, or feel cool in the wilderness, it’s a rugged keepsake with heart.
Engagement Anniversary Gift for Her
9. Custom Engagement Location Art
You never forget the spot where you got engaged. Whether it was in your favorite park, on a beach at sunset, or just your kitchen in pajamas—marking the place with custom art feels especially meaningful. These prints typically feature a heart over your location on a map, your names, and the date. It’s simple, sentimental, and sure to earn a prominent place on the wall or shelf.
10. Personalized Jewelry Dish
Rings, earrings, little charms—she needs a place to keep all those tiny treasures. A personalized trinket dish does the trick while also serving as a daily reminder of your journey together. Choose one with your initials, engagement date, or a short romantic quote. It’s the kind of thing she’ll use every day, and every glance will take her back to the “yes” moment.
11. Keepsake Memory Book
If she’s the sentimental type (and let’s be honest, most of us are when it comes to love), a guided memory book can be a gift that keeps on giving. These aren’t blank journals—they come with prompts for things like “Our Favorite Dates” and “What I First Noticed About You.” It’s a fun way to reflect on your relationship so far and dream about the future. Fill out a few pages ahead of time to make it even more special.
12. Birthstone Necklace
There’s something timeless about a birthstone necklace—especially when it’s tied to your relationship. Choose her birthstone, yours, or the month you got engaged. The result is a piece of jewelry that’s subtle enough for daily wear but carries a story only the two of you really know. Bonus: you can find versions in gold, rose gold, or silver depending on her style.
13. Candle with a Personalized Label
A candle might sound basic, but dress it up with a custom label and it turns into a swoon-worthy keepsake. Look for ones where you can add your names, the date of your engagement, or even a cheeky inside joke. Whether it’s a warm vanilla scent or something more woodsy, she’ll light it on cozy nights and think of you every time the flame flickers.
14. Custom Star Map
Sure, it sounds poetic—but it’s also real science. A custom star map captures exactly what the sky looked like on the night you got engaged. It’s romantic, a little nerdy, and incredibly personal. Most versions come with the date, location, and a sweet caption like “The Night We Said Yes.” Whether framed or mounted on canvas, it’s a gift that’s both decorative and deeply meaningful.
15. Handwritten Recipe Cutting Board
If she loves cooking—or just loves meaningful decor—a wooden cutting board engraved with a family recipe or a love note in your handwriting hits all the right notes. It’s the kind of thing that blends utility with nostalgia. Not only is it beautiful, but it also feels like a family heirloom in the making.